how to run the feasibility study so the answer holds.
Most communities decide to build an incubator and then commission a study to justify it. Butte, Montana asked it the other way around in 2026: whether one should exist at all, what shape it should take, and who should run it. That order matters because the study is small money governing a large decision. A seventy thousand dollar study sits on top of roughly four million dollars of build-and-operate commitment over ten years. Flip the order and you get a building with a ribbon on it and nobody who knows what to do on Tuesday. Butte scoped its study to finish before the grant working group had to commit a dollar to a site, which is the order we would recommend to anyone.
Five things, in sequence, each one closing before the next opens. Existing conditions first: the real inventory of economic development and workforce assets, and the university’s actual disclosure and licensing pipeline rather than its brochure. Then the founders, found by reaching past the usual suspects with surveys and structured interviews, because the people who show up to the chamber breakfast are rarely the ones who will rent a desk. Then demand and benchmarks, against comparable rural and university-town programs, including the ones that failed and the ones alive only on subsidy. Then site and money: candidate buildings walked in person, capital and operating costs priced at real local wages and rents, and a multi-year sustainability projection that survives contact with a council budget. Last, governance and model: named roles for each partner, the succession question most studies skip, a service mix tuned to the founder profile the interviews actually turned up, and, if the answer is yes, a ninety-day pre-opening checklist. We keep one from our own facility.
The hardest part of an incubator is the Tuesday. Amanda has run ten years of them as Executive Director of MatchBOX, and that record is what makes the feasibility arithmetic honest: what a cohort of ten ventures costs to run, what staffing ratio keeps members from drifting, what a mayor needs in his hand at the State of the City. In Lafayette the answer was a book on creative communities, handed over with instructions about which chapters to read carefully. The city floated $1.5 million in economic development bonds to renovate a historic building leased from the public library for a dollar a year, and then came 25 fundraising asks of the old-guard business establishment, and 25 yeses. The asks were designed to do two jobs: fund the buildout and give the establishment a real stake in whether the newcomers succeeded. Any study worth its fee should tell you who your 25 are.
A feasibility study tells you if, and a model tells you what, so a verdict should arrive with a model attached, simple enough for a council member to argue with. Ours for Butte ran on four dials: ventures admitted per year, five-year survival, direct jobs per surviving company, and average wage. At eight ventures a year, 45 percent survival, four jobs each, and a $52,000 wage, year ten holds about 40 surviving companies, 160 direct jobs, and roughly $21 million in local economic value, on a commitment of about $4 million. Every one of those assumptions gets replaced by the town’s own evidence as the study runs, and the model is built in the open so the council can see the decision’s own shape before anyone signs anything.
A good study can say no, or not yet, or a different thing entirely. Often the different thing is already standing. MBXax carried the MatchBOX accelerator into ten rural Indiana counties by training local partners to run it, in towns with a coworking room and a chamber director and no budget for construction. The Local put entrepreneurs into two white-box storefronts at $500 a month with utilities included, on 30, 60 and 90 day residencies, and the independent assessment of the district it sat in put the value generated at about a hundred times the public dollars in. The cheapest accelerator is frequently a lease and a curriculum, and a study that cannot recommend that is a study that was told the answer before it started.
